The Witch is Back

The Witch is Back By Brittany Geragotelis


To anyone who’s ever been judged, bullied, rejected, teased, ignored, or targeted . . . you are extraordinary and one day others will know it, too.


ACKNOWLEDGMENTS



I owe so much thanks to those who had a hand in making this book happen.

To everyone at Simon & Schuster—Justin Chanda, Bernadette Cruz, Paul Crichton, Lucy Cummins, Catherine Laudone—thank you for making my publishing dreams come true. You’ve been incredible. Christian Trimmer: Your enthusiasm for this book has been unmatched. Thanks for all your editorial expertise!

I couldn’t have done any of this without my wonderful team: Kevan Lyon at the Marsal Lyon Agency (Lit agent extraordinaire); Taryn Fagerness at the Taryn Fagerness Agency (Rockstar of the foreign market); Brandy Rivers at Gersh (Queen of Hollywood); Deborah Wolfe at Frankfurt Kurnit Klein & Selz (My legal bodyguards); Samantha Martin (PR maven), Sandy Han and Anna Osgoodby at Media Maison. I’m so grateful to have you all on my dream team.

Of course, my besties are the ones who keep me sane and happy in this often insane world. You’re my biggest supporters. You make me laugh. And you pick me up when I’m down. Hugs and kisses to: Tammy West, Amanda Healy, Jessica Grant, Kate Chapman, Mary Eustace, Courtney McCabe, Darcey West, Rebecca Schuman, Alicia Chouinard, Sue Chouinard, Colleen Woodsmith and Siena Koncsol. Also, I have to say a HUGE THANK YOU to everyone at A.G., Wattpad and Pips Place NYC. I love you all!

Lastly, the love and support of my family has meant the world to me. Your advice, positivity, and encouragement has kept me going over the years. Thanks so much to: Mom, Dad, Jacey, Amy, Cody, Cash, my aunts and uncles (both related and not), Andrea, Price, Ryan, Katy, Chelle, and Maya. Thank you for always believing in me. Matt—you are the reason all my dreams have come true. Thank you for loving me. You amaze me every single day.





June 4, 1692




The funny thing about betrayal is that by the time you know about it, the damage has already been done.

Bridget Bishop should know. Her life had been surrounded by it as of late.

And as if the betrayal itself weren’t bad enough, when it came from your friends, family, and community members, it’s an especially hard slap in the face. The realization that you were cared for so little that you deserved the public humiliation and heartache coming to you, was enough to send a person over the edge.

Luckily, Bridget still had the love and support of her only daughter, Christian, to keep her fighting for her life, otherwise she might have saved the executioners the trouble and done the job herself.

The others who’d been accused hadn’t been blessed with this kind of loyalty from their families.

Bridget looked around her cell and then let her eyes sweep across the dungeon to those shackled to the floors and walls. Dozens of people filled the space, one more hopeless than the next. But Bridget felt as if she couldn’t complain too much, given the fact that people like Tituba, Sarah Osborne, and Sarah Good had been confined to the prison much longer than she had.

And not everyone inhabiting the jail were witches.

That’s not to say that most of them weren’t. The majority were members of the Cleri, while others were members of other covens or simply innocent bystanders. Well, innocent might not have been the right word for some of those included in the trials, considering the darkness of their past actions, but they certainly weren’t practicing witchcraft.

Bridget turned to the three women closest to her own cell. The two Sarahs and Tituba had been among the first accused and therefore had experienced the brunt of the initial backlash. Osborne was in there by mistake, having been shunned by the community because she’d stopped going to church. Of course, she’d only stopped attending because an illness had taken over her body, but nobody wanted to hear that fact. Still, church or no church, a witch she was not.

Good and Tituba, however, were both members of the coven Supre, and neither had ever hurt another living soul. That wasn’t the purpose of the coven after all. Bridget knew this because the Cleri had convened with the Supre at annual gatherings. The sister coven had always been kind and otherwise harmless.

Lord knows why Tituba eventually confessed to practicing dark magic, saying that Good and Osborne had convinced her to sign her soul over to the Devil. Those of us who knew the women knew it wasn’t true, but nothing could be done to convince her to change her story. Bridget could only guess that the pressure of being hated by the whole town had driven the woman mad.

Sarah Good, however, seemed to be taking things the hardest. She’d always been an outcast in Salem, but had managed to find a home with her fellow Supre members. They’d been the only ones to overlook the fact that she was homeless, often looked dirty and unkempt, and wasn’t above going door-to-door to ask for charity. Given Good’s already stunted relationship with the townspeople, the realization that they found her capable of doing harm to others shouldn’t have been all too surprising.

But apparently it was that, coupled with Tituba’s treachery and the fact that her husband and even her four-year-old daughter had testified against her in court, that had worn Good down until she was practically skin and bones.

When she bothered to talk—which was rare by this point—it was only to claim her innocence. It cut through Bridget every time she heard the woman sobbing in the dark at night.

“Visitors!” one of the guards announced as he opened the heavy wooden door and ushered a handful of people into the room.

Though Bridget recognized the four women, she’d never talked to them herself. She did, however, know their husbands, as they frequented the pub she owned before she’d been dragged into this god-awful place. Bridget had heard the men complaining about their nagging wives and therefore knew them to be judgmental gossipers who looked down at most others in the town.

Bridget had a growing suspicion that the women’s visit wouldn’t be pleasant.

The four walked over to the cell next to Bridget’s and stopped to stare stone-faced at Tituba and the two Sarahs. The woman who took up the front of the pack placed her arms behind her back as if to keep herself from reaching out and getting too close to the accused.

“Disgusting pieces of filth you are,” the visitor whispered, squinting her eyes at the three women. “How dare you attempt to harm our children in your quest to do Satan’s bidding.”

“Witches!” another shouted.

“Thieves!”

“Dismissing the church . . . ,” the leader said to Sarah Osborne, “. . . a lowly slave . . . ,” to Tituba, “. . . and a dirty, murderess beggar,” finally fixing her stare on Sarah Good. “I always knew you were the Devil’s spawn, not worthy of our respect or company. Now the rest of the world knows it, too.”

Silence filled the room as the free stood before the prisoners. Finally, a voice broke through, surprising all of them.

“I have not done that which you accuse me of,” Sarah Good said quietly. Her eyes were swollen from so much crying, and though she was one of the youngest being held, she looked at least twenty years older than her time on Earth.

“Then why hath your own family forsaken you?” the woman spat back nastily. “God did not even find you worthy of motherhood and took your child away before you could do it harm as well.”

There was an audible gasp at this and Bridget wasn’t sure whether it had come from the rest of the women in the room or from Sarah herself. Either way, everyone knew the woman had gone too far.


By now, it was common knowledge that Sarah had been pregnant at the time of her arrest, and despite the stress and horrible living conditions, had managed to give birth to a baby girl she’d named Mercy. No doubt a plea to the Lord to be set free. However, her plan hadn’t worked and Sarah had watched desperately as her own kin perished in the jail. It was hard enough losing a child, but to then be told it was because of your own wickedness—that is a cross no one should have to bear.

“Ladies, it would be a good idea if you were to leave now,” Bridget warned, drawing the attention over to herself. The distraction worked and the group took a few steps toward her.

“Oh, Bridget . . .” The lady clucked her tongue as if she were scolding the aging woman. “I should think you are not in a position to be ordering anyone around. Besides, you are just as vile as she is.”

“You do not know what you say,” Bridget returned, sitting up a little straighter from her place on the floor.

“Oh, I think I do. But that does not matter, because God knows what you have done and He will punish you for your unholy atrocities,” the woman said, pointing her finger at Bridget and then at the other women locked up. “He will punish each and every one of you.”

Then, without a backward glance, the women turned and began to head back the way they came. Besides the sound of their shoes hitting the stone floor, the only other noise was the sobs coming from Sarah.

Bridget watched as they left, and promised herself that they would get what was coming to them.

They all would.

And then, with a hollow clanking sound loud enough to wake the dead, Bridget and the others were locked inside, their fates sealed along with the door.





Chapter One




As the door slammed on the women’s fate, my eyes flew open with a start. I searched the room in a panicky attempt to figure out where I was. At the same time, I willed my hands to move, still feeling the weight of the shackles on my wrists. Relief washed over me as I was able to bring them up to my face and brush away the hair that was matted to my forehead.

It was just another dream.

Oh, who was I kidding? By now I knew enough to understand that the dreams I had were more like memories from the past—my ancestor’s past to be more accurate. And as often as I’d had these little trips down memory lane, I still couldn’t get used to the feeling of betrayal and fear that they left me saddled with. This, along with the fact that all the horrific things that I was seeing had actually happened—that my great-grandmother several times over, Bridget Bishop, had been the first person hanged during the Salem witch trials—and well, you can see why I couldn’t count on getting acceptable beauty sleep.

Luckily, there was a spell for that.

Lately though, my dreams had branched out to include the lives of others accused during the trials. Sarah Good and Tituba, especially, had become regulars in my flashbacks, and disturbing as it was, I was beginning to feel connected to them in a way that only someone who’d lived through that awful time period could. Most people had to search ancestry.com to discover what was on their family trees. My relatives were hung from ours.

“Had!” a voice called, breaking through my thoughts and bringing me back to reality. “Breakfast in ten and then we’ll go for that run?”

A glance over at my bedside clock showed that it was just a little past 8 a.m. I sighed heavily.

So much for sleeping in during the summer.

“Okay, Dad!” I shouted back. “I’ll be there in a minute!”

As much as I longed to pull the covers over my head and go back to sleep, I flung them back dramatically and shimmied my way off the bed until my feet hit the floor. I couldn’t exactly back out of our morning workout, since I’d been the one to suggest it the night before.

Ever since Mom had died at the hands of the evil coven, the Parrishables, I’d been putting more of an effort into spending time with my dad whenever possible. For a while, I’d thought I’d lost both of my parents in the fire that had killed most of the adults in the Cleri. But then Dad had shown up, untouched and alive. Not that Samuel Parris hadn’t tried to do away with him, too. He’d just been luckier than Mom and the others when the Parrishables had finally hunted him down.

The Parrishables.

The dark coven run by Salem native and overall bad guy, Samuel Parris, tried to destroy the Cleri several months before, hoping that it would make them the ultimate superpower when it came to the magical world. And they’d almost succeeded. Until they’d come up against the younger members of our coven. That’s where they’d messed up.

Much to my shock, it turned out that the Parrishables were actually after me. Apparently I’m some kind of magical powerhouse. I’d always known that my casting skills were superior to those of the rest of my coven, but until I’d gone up against Samuel, I hadn’t realized the extent of my abilities. Once armed with that knowledge, we became an unstoppable force.

In the end, it had taken all of the twitches (our term for teen witch) in the Cleri—including our relatives who had already passed on—to defeat an evil that had begun in Salem.

Which brought me back to my dream. Memory. Whatever.

Yawning in protest, I walked into my bathroom and looked at myself in the mirror. “Ugh,” I mumbled, squeezing my eyes shut against what I saw. Then, without another peek, I said, “Renewbus freshimo perfecto.”

As my mouth began to tingle and take on the taste of mint, I felt the rest of the changes happening. I didn’t need to look to know makeup was being applied, hair was being smoothed, and my skin was taking on a dewy glow. When I felt the spell wind down, I opened my eyes again slowly. The transformation was amazing, but since I used this particular spell so often, the result wasn’t exactly surprising anymore. While I preferred actually going through my whole beauty routine, the shortcut was a lifesaver on those days when I didn’t have time to get ready. Or in this case, when I’d dreamed of Bridget Bishop the night before and had the bags on my face to prove it.

Thanks to the Renewbus spell, sparkly gold shadow now swept across my lids, making my eyes shine brightly. Dollops of pink danced on the apples of my cheeks and my full lips were perfectly glossed with just a hint of color to them. My dark hair, which had been a hot mess just a few seconds before, was now pulled back into a braid that swept across my forehead and then back into a ponytail in the middle of my head. I smiled at myself in the mirror, and caught a glimpse of my too-white-to-be-natural teeth. I was practically a walking toothpaste commercial.

A slightly more awake version of myself headed back to my room and pulled on a pair of black Soffe shorts that I retrieved from my drawer, along with a sports bra and oversize tank. I snagged my tennis shoes from the corner and laced them up in double-knotted bows.

A girl should always be prepared for any situation, and the last thing I needed was to trip over a lace and give myself a reason to get a nose job. I was sort of attached to the one I already had, thank-you-very-much.

“Had, breakfast is—”

My dad let the sentence trail off as I appeared at the kitchen door and then plopped down at the table.

“Impressive spread,” I said as I looked at the pancakes, bacon, eggs, fruit, yogurt, and toast that was piled in the middle of the table. I scooped up some plain nonfat yogurt, topped it off with blueberries, raspberries, and strawberries, and then settled back into my chair to eat.


“That’s all you’re having?” he asked me. I could tell he was disappointed I wasn’t eating more and instantly felt guilty.

“Sorry, Dad, but if you want me to actually be able to run after this, I can’t exactly eat heavy now,” I said apologetically.

“Oh, uh, right. Of course,” Dad said, like the thought hadn’t occurred to him until now. And it probably hadn’t. I watched him scratch his head absently as he looked around at all the food that was going to go to waste. “It’s just that they say breakfast is the most important meal of the day and all. . . .”

I didn’t ask him who “they” were, because I already knew. He was talking about the parenting books and chat rooms. It had been like this a lot lately. Him going overboard on his parental duties, as if he’d forgotten everything he’d ever known about being a parent. Suddenly, he was worried about me eating three meals a day, whether I was doing all of my homework, and if I was dating anyone. The week before, he’d even asked me if I had a bedtime.

But I got it.

Without Mom around, we were both sort of learning how to live together again. Just the two of us. I mean, Mom had always handled the day-to-day household stuff before. So now whenever Dad was home and not traveling, he tended to take things a bit too seriously. And as much as I liked the attention, it was a bit much.

At first I’d been dealing with a healthy dose of fear over the prospect of his leaving town again for work. After all, the last time he’d gone, we were all almost killed and I didn’t think I’d ever see him again. So, you can understand my apprehension. But Dad had to pay the bills and we both needed to move on, so I’d taken Dad’s spurts of overcompensation—like this morning’s banquet-size breakfast—with a grain of salt, always reminding myself that it could be worse.

A lot worse.

I took a big bite of my breakfast and ate it like it was the best thing I’d ever tasted. “The fruit and yogurt is really good though, Dad. Totally what I wanted,” I said, trying to wipe the disappointment off his face. It seemed to work and he smiled slightly.

As I went for another scoop, there was a knock at the back door and I heard the familiar turn of the metal knob. The sound brought me back to the dream I’d had and I couldn’t help but shiver despite the warmth of the kitchen. Even months later, I was constantly on edge, waiting for the Parrishables to come back. But running on fear was no way to live, so I forced myself to stay glued to my seat and fought through the thought that something bad was about to happen. The only way to get over fear was to walk through it. My mom had taught me that.

“Hey, Had,” Asher said, breaking the silence and kissing me on the cheek as he came up behind me. I relaxed as he took a seat at the table. “Wow, Mr. Bishop, are you feeding an army?”

“Apparently not,” Dad said, frowning as he placed a few eggs and fruit onto his own plate.

“Need some help getting rid of it?” Asher asked, eyeing the food hungrily, but not yet moving to take a plate.

I could see the instant relief in my Dad’s face, and my heart swelled with gratitude for my boyfriend. Since we’d arrived home from the cabin after defeating the Parrishables, he’d been the model guy: taking me out on dates, going to games to watch me cheer, and hanging around the house to get to know my dad better. All things I would’ve never thought possible when we’d first met. In fact, given that our whole relationship had started off as a lie, I thought we were doing pretty well.

It was hard to believe that less than a year ago Asher had been secretly batting for Team Parrishable. Back then, he was just this amazingly hot guy with jet-black hair, styled in a metro-looking faux-hawk and eyes that seemed like they could pierce my soul. And his lips?

Very kissable.

After some flirting, a few major fights with other witches, and an innocent—but awesome—sleepover, I’d found out he’d been working with the enemy. Well, kind of. Turned out, my nemesis, Samuel Parris, had been holding Asher’s sister hostage and was threatening to hurt her unless he did as he was told, which included infiltrating the Cleri and relaying our secrets.

I was pretty pissed at first, but could hardly blame him for trying to save his sister. And by this time, I’d already fallen in love with him, which made everything more complicated. In the end, Asher had stepped up and helped us take down Samuel. Literally. He even jumped in front of a speeding spell to save me, risking his life in the process.

Now, back in the nonmagicking world, with Samuel gone and Asher’s sister back home safe and sound, we could finally be a normal couple. Well, as normal as a couple of twitches could be, anyway.

And it was amazing.

“Help yourself,” Dad said, gesturing to the food in front of us and popping a blueberry into his mouth.

Asher didn’t wait for him to offer again and immediately dug in.



After our run, I freshened up and headed over to Asher’s. Slipping in through the side gate, I found my boyfriend—man, I loved the sound of that—my boyfriend—the words were totally delicious—standing in the backyard a few feet away from a man in an oversize trench coat and striped fedora. The stranger had his back turned to us, so I couldn’t make out who he was, but I was instantly suspicious.

Furrowing my brows, I took in the scene before me. Who wears a trench coat in the middle of the summer? People who are up to no good, that’s who. I began to fall back into a fighting stance, but before I could do anything, Asher let loose a spell of his own.

“Flameeble ignitus!” he yelled at the ominous figure.

Almost instantly, a puff of smoke exploded at the guy’s feet, creating a steady stream of white, which circled and covered the area in wisps. I had no idea what was happening, but the man in the hat wasn’t moving.

“Dammit!” Asher said loudly as he walked over to the man and pulled off his hat forcefully. Then he began to fan the area until the smoke dissipated. Thoroughly confused, I made my way across the yard until I was close enough to see what was going on.

“Did you just turn him into a mannequin?!” I asked, slightly horrified and impressed at the same time. “Asher, I’m sure you had your reasons, but . . .”

“Huh?” he asked, looking over at me as I walked up. “No. I mean, I know. He already was a mannequin. I was trying to cast a flame, but all I ended up doing was setting off a smoke bomb. Great for stupid high school pranks, not helpful in defeating bad guys.”

Waves of relief rushed over me.

Though I was embarrassed to admit it, I had thought for just a moment that maybe Asher was back to his old tricks. That he was using less-than-savory magic for his own purposes again. It was only for a moment though, and then I remembered that the lying, sneaky Asher wasn’t the real him. But I couldn’t help the knee-jerk reaction. Apparently I still had some trust issues that I needed to work through in that regard.

“Well, maybe Brighton will be good for us after all,” I said, seeing how frustrated he was by the failed spell.

“I’m just a little rusty, that’s all. I didn’t use magic at all when we first met, and lately I’ve been too busy to practice,” Asher said, placing the hat back on the dummy’s head and giving me a pointed look. This was his way of letting me know—not so subtly, I might add—that this was because of me.


The truth was, spending all our time together had made it difficult for either of us to focus on magic lately. Except for the kind we were making together. But that wouldn’t come in handy if we were going up against guys like the Parrishables again, which was still a possibility, considering that many of Samuel’s followers had run off into the night after we’d banished their leader.

“Brighton will give us both a chance to catch up on the things that we’ve let slide,” Asher said.

I walked over to him and threw my arms around his neck.

“I still think we could have done that here,” I said, kissing him on the cheek softly. Then I moved my lips up to his temple and kissed him there, before heading over to the space below his ear and lingering for a moment. His body stiffened beneath mine. “Then we’d be able to be alone. I bet it’d be easier to concentrate without all those other people around.”

“You’re the only thing I’d concentrate on if we stayed here, and you know it,” Asher said, pulling away from me but keeping his arm on my waist. “You know I love you, Had, but not all of us are magical geniuses who don’t need to practice their craft. I’ve been letting that side of my life slide these past few months. Don’t get me wrong—it’s totally been worth it, but still . . . Let me put it this way: I respect you for being the kick-ass witch that you are, but I want to at least be in the same stratosphere as you. You might not need me to save you from evil, but I don’t want to be a liability, either.”

As a witch, I understood what he was trying to say. Magic was important to both of us, and in a way, it should trump our relationship. But as a girl, all I heard was that Asher would rather go to some summer magic intensive than spend time alone with me.

Ugh, is this what it’s like to be in love? Blinded by rainbows and unicorns, and sappy soundtracks that played in your head whenever you were around each other, and having all logic and sense of self thrown out the window? Had I turned into the kind of girl who put a boy before her magic?

All of these thoughts must have been running across my face, because Asher pulled me back in for a kiss. “We’ll still have plenty of time for us this summer,” he promised. “But I do think we need to make magic a priority again. What happens if Samuel comes back and I can’t even do a simple flame-throwing spell? With my skills as they are, I’ll only be able to give him smoke inhalation.”

“Hopefully we won’t have to test that theory,” I said, willing myself to believe my own words.

Ever since we’d been back, the Cleri had been getting together at night to perform protection spells and location spells to ensure that we wouldn’t be caught off guard again. So far, it looked like Samuel and the rest of the Parrishables were gone, but none of us were naive enough to stop with the precautions.

“I agree,” Asher said, looking into my eyes. “But if it’s not him, you know it could be somebody else. There are a lot of bad people out there who, just like Samuel, are itching to get their hands on our power. Your power.”

I frowned. He was probably right, but the last thing I wanted to do was worry about all the bad things that could happen. Not when things were finally starting to feel normal again. I wanted to get back to being a normal twitch, with a normal—but abnormally hot—boyfriend, whose only worry was leading her normal coven and heading off to the normal college of her choice. I didn’t want to be carted off to some summer intensive I’d never been to before, where I was going to once again be forced to focus 100 percent on spells. It sounded too much like summer school, and tests and homework were so not my idea of a good time. I wanted to find a balance, a way to have it all.

But I couldn’t ignore what Asher was saying. We had to stay on top of our magical game, and since Jackson, who’d been in charge of training us, had expired in the fire along with our parents, there was no one to run our magic classes anymore. So, after a few emergency meetings between the guardians of the remaining Cleri members, the adults had decided the best thing to do would be to send us all off for the summer, where we could learn more about our heritage in a safe and supervised environment.

Just the way I fantasized spending my first summer with Asher. Not.

The only catch was that the Brighton Summer Intensive was an exclusive program—one that twitches had to be invited to attend. Which meant that it wasn’t as simple as our parents just handing us over for a month. We had to prove that we were among the best and brightest in the witching world. I’d received invitations to attend in the past, but since it fell during the same time that I was away with my squad at cheer camp, I’d always politely declined. Still, it was an honor to be invited, and this year, most of the Cleri had made the cut. This was mainly due to their ability to survive the war with Samuel, but none of them were complaining.

So me, Asher, his sister Abby, Sascha, Jasmine, Fallon, and Jinx were all welcomed to come to the witch-owned cabin in Colorado for the summer. Peter had been invited as well, but was stuck in summer school. Poor kid was totally broken up about it, worrying that he was going to lose his place in the coven if he didn’t go. No matter how many times I told him this wasn’t true he wouldn’t believe me.

“Maybe you’re right,” I said, with a sigh.

Asher smiled at me, brushing my long dark hair out of my face. “Think of it this way: It’ll be like our first vacation together . . . just us and sixty strangers.”