White Rose Black Forest

Franka picked a hot-water bottle out of the closet, the memories of her youth coming at the mere sight of it—nights cuddled up under blankets, her eyes drifting shut as her mother sang her to sleep.

She had never meant to stay here this long. There were too many ghosts. But now she had little choice. Leaving the cabin would mean leaving him and giving the Gestapo their victory. She took the hot-water bottle out to the kitchen and poured the water in once it had heated. It felt good in her hands, like it was giving life back to her. She hugged it, feeling the warmth in her chest, before returning to the bedroom. Could he really be German? Why would he have said those English words in his sleep? Perhaps this was all simpler than she’d made out, and she could drop him off at the local hospital when the roads cleared in a few days. Maybe she’d misheard him talking in his sleep. She didn’t speak English and had only heard a few words spoken in front of her. Perhaps he hadn’t said anything at all. Perhaps he really was Hauptman Werner Graf of the Luftwaffe. Franka felt her heart drop at the thought that he wasn’t who she thought he was, that he was one of them. Was he a Luftwaffe flier? She had seen the propaganda films that showed foreigners coming to join the glorious German Reich. It seemed unlikely. If he was Luftwaffe, she would hand him over to the authorities as soon as he came to, and that would be that.

The bedroom went black as she blew out the oil lamp at her bedside. No. He had said those English words. She had heard them. She still could hear them, could still sound them out on her tongue. He wasn’t Hauptman Werner Graf of the Luftwaffe. Why had he been lying in the snow in the mountains of the Black Forest? He couldn’t have been there for more than a few minutes when she’d found him; otherwise she would have come upon a corpse. If he was a spy or a prisoner of war, the penalty for helping him would be death. She could handle that. The National Socialists couldn’t take anything more from her now. Not when she had nothing left for them to take.

Franka turned over in the bed, pulling the thick blankets up to her chin so that only her face was exposed. Beneath the bedcovers was the only warm place in the house apart from the fire. The man only had one blanket, and the hole she’d made in the floor would let in a draft. She got out of bed, taking the key to the man’s bedroom door. She put on a nightgown, and a coat over that, before tiptoeing away. The house was still. She unlocked the door, put a hand on the door handle, and knocked with her other hand as she opened it.

“Hallo?” she whispered. “Are you awake, Herr Graf?”

He was lying in the bed, but she could see that his eyes were open. For a horrible second she thought he might have been dead, but soon he turned his head to her.

“I am awake, Fr?ulein.”

“Are you warm enough?”

“I’m fine, thank you.”

She didn’t take his word for it. It was colder in his room than hers, and he didn’t have as many blankets. She’d left the curtains open, and the light of the moon was streaming in. The features of his face were visible in the half-light. She took his hand. She hadn’t planned on touching him, just wanted to see how cold he was. His eyes came to hers.

“You’re freezing,” she said. “Why didn’t you ask me for another blanket?”

“I don’t want to cause you any more trouble.”

“Nonsense. There’s no use suffering when there are more blankets in the closet.” She let go of his hand and opened the closet. She took out a thick blanket and spread it over him. “This will keep you warm.” He was staring at her, and she stepped back. “I’m going into town tomorrow. The roads will be closed, but we need food and I can’t bear the thought of the pain you must be in.” She paused for an answer that didn’t come. “It’s obvious that I can’t bring you in with me, but if you’d like, I can report your presence here to the local Gestapo.” It was her turn to stare at him now.

“That won’t be necessary, Fr?ulein. The local police are not of concern to me. As I mentioned previously, I’m handling some sensitive matters on behalf of the war effort right now. Alerting anyone to my presence here wouldn’t be prudent at this time.”

“So you don’t want me to report that you’re here to anyone? They could tell the Luftwaffe, your superior officer, whom sent you up in that airplane.”

“Really, there’s no need. I’ll leave you as soon as the roads are clear. Until then, I’ll be your grateful guest.”

Franka wondered if he knew how long his legs were going to take to heal or if he was being deliberately ignorant. She was certain of one thing, however: he wasn’t an English-speaking Luftwaffe pilot.

“As you wish.” She turned to leave.

“Fr?ulein, how did you get me here?”

“I dragged you on a sled.”

“You dragged me back here unconscious?” His eyes were wide in the darkness. He held his hands together in front of him as if he were praying. “You are a truly remarkable person. I am forever in your debt.”

“You need to sleep now. Is there anything else you need?”

“A chamber pot, perhaps? Just in case.”

“Of course,” she answered, and went to the kitchen. She found a basin that would do the job and brought it back to him. He accepted it with a smile and thanked her once more. Franka closed the door behind her, turning the key in the lock. She determined not to use the name Werner Graf anymore. Saying it out loud demeaned them both.



Franka awoke with the dawn. The night had brought a deeper sleep than she’d enjoyed for many months. The man’s presence in the house had in some way blunted the memories that found her in the dark. The memories were always worse at night, and sleeping alone had become torture. There was comfort to be drawn from his presence here, and she felt it. She had already done so much for him, and he for her. He was the first thing that came to her mind as she opened her eyes. She wondered if he’d slept, and if he was in pain. She wondered if his bones were still set properly with the splints she’d made, and when, if ever, she’d learn the truth about him. The floor felt like ice, and she searched for her slippers, then slid her feet into them before venturing to the window. Pushing back the curtains revealed the winter sun in a cloudless, cobalt-blue sky. The snow was as it had been the night before. Doubts crept in. Did she really have to make this trip into town today? Could she wait? They had little food left, and she couldn’t leave him lying in misery until the roads opened back up. Who knew when that would be? The roads up here could be closed for weeks at a time, although that was before the brutal efficiency of the Nazis. It was decided, then: she would go into town today. She would go all the way into Freiburg. She would find the supplies she needed in the city, and no one was looking for her—she had no one to hide from.

Franka went to his room and put her ear against the door. There was no noise from inside, so she drew back and went to the kitchen. The skis were still against the wall where she’d left them the night before. Ten miles was a ridiculous distance to attempt on skis, particularly considering her lack of practice these past few years. It was less than two to the main road into Freiburg, and she was confident in her ability to hitch a ride into town from there. She restocked the fireplaces in both the living room and the kitchen. The fires would be long extinguished by the time she returned but would provide some warmth while she was gone.

It had only been a few days since she’d been in Freiburg, but it seemed like years ago. She was a different person now. Those few days she’d spent in the city the week before were a blur. She closed her eyes, trying to forget.

Eoin Dempsey's books