“I heard you’re in Cleveland now,” Malone said, pouring as he talked.
“Yeah. I moved there in August of ’34 when I was still working for the bureau. Got offered the job as safety director about a year after that,” Eliot answered, taking the glass Malone handed him; he sipped it appreciatively. He never used to drink. He’d never wanted to be a hypocrite. But Prohibition was over.
“What the hell is a safety director, Ness?” Malone asked. He stared down into the amber liquid in his own glass. He didn’t really want to drink right now. Once he started, he might not stop.
“I’m in charge of the police and the fire department. Basically . . . the public safety guy.”
“You’re the chief of chiefs?”
“Something like that.” Eliot spoke in the same slow manner Malone remembered. It made him seem older than his years and forced patience and attention on the listener, and Malone had always found it endearing.
“Last I heard, you were hunting moonshiners in Kentucky,” Malone pressed.
“Yeah. And I’m never going back.” Ness set his empty glass on the table.
Malone added another finger. “That bad?” he asked.
“I’d take Al Capone and his boys any day.”
“You got mob troubles in Cleveland?”
“Yeah. They’re everywhere. But I have a whole new set of problems. You know what’s going on in my city?”
Malone’s brows shot up. “Your city? Cleveland is your city now? I thought Chicago was your city.”
“I’m responsible to the people in Cleveland now. And Cleveland has a madman roaming the streets, cutting people’s heads off.”
“I’ve been a long ways from Cleveland,” Malone said. “Are you talking about the murders? I know a little. But you’re going to have to fill me in.”
“They’re calling him the Torso Killer. The Mad Butcher of Kingsbury Run. I’ve never seen the like. Not here. Not in Kentucky. Not ever.” Ness sighed. “The thing is . . . I understood Capone. His crimes made sense. It was business. Money. Power. Control. I don’t understand this guy. Chopping people up. Dumping their naked corpses in plain sight. Men. Women. Doesn’t seem to matter.”
Ness took another swallow like he needed the reinforcement. “Some of the bodies have been found by kids. Scarred for life now, those kids. You decide to skip school and go fishing and end up finding a human head, rolled up in a pair of trousers, sitting beneath a tree? How does a kid recover from that? Some other boys were playing ball near the Run, on a slope they call Jackass Hill. Their ball rolled down the hill; they chased it and found two dead men without heads or genitals, one of ’em still wearing his socks.”
Malone winced.
“Oh, it gets worse,” Eliot said. “The third victim, a woman named Flo Polillo, was chopped up and divided between two produce baskets. The woman who found the baskets thought the woman’s torso was a couple of hams.” He grimaced. “People are hungry right now, Malone. Luckily, the woman was not as desperate as some, and she went and told the butcher across the way that she thought he’d been robbed. Imagine her shock when she discovered the hams were human flanks. That’s the garbage going on in Cleveland. Not raids on distilleries. Not disruption of supply lines. Not good old cops and robbers or gangsters and agents. I can handle all that.”
“I can see why you miss Capone,” Malone murmured.
“I do. Damn it. I do,” Ness said. “Like most everywhere else, the food lines in Cleveland are long and jobs are few, and the misery is everywhere you look. And . . . all of that misery makes sense. I don’t like it, but it makes sense.”
For a moment both men were quiet, thoughtful.
“What doesn’t make sense is a guy who chops people up for seemingly no rhyme or reason,” Ness said, adding, “I don’t even know where to begin with that.”
“It doesn’t make sense to you. But that doesn’t mean it doesn’t make sense,” Malone offered. A wise little girl had said that to him once. He’d never forgotten it.
“Yeah?” Ness scoffed. “Well . . . so far it doesn’t make sense to my guys either. We’re all scratching our heads. All the old rules don’t seem to apply with these murders.”
“Like what?”
“The victims don’t have any connection to each other, beyond the fact that they lived in or around Kingsbury Run. The papers have said all the victims were indigent, but that’s not true, not exactly. They were poor, but not so much poorer than anyone else. They frequented establishments that aren’t highbrow, but that’s just the few we were able to identify. The rest could be saints and angels for all we really know.”
“Do you think the Butcher knows them?” Malone pressed.
“You understand how these things usually work. Murders are almost never committed by strangers.”
“But you don’t think that’s what’s going on here?”
“No. None of the people who knew the first victim, Edward Andrassy, are even people of interest at this point. Andrassy wasn’t an especially swell fella, but his family loved him. His parents grieved him. It’s been hell on them, the endless interviews trying to turn something up, anything that would give us a clue as to who killed him so we can connect the dots to the others.”
“How many now?”
“Ten. There was one in September of ’34 that hasn’t been included in the tally. A woman’s torso was found on the shores of Lake Erie. She’s never been identified, and they weren’t even sure she was murdered. They thought it may have been someone who fell overboard, drowned, and her body was possibly torn up by a propeller.”
“The Lady of the Lake.” Malone remembered now. That scenario had never seemed likely to him. A woman falls out of a boat and drowns on Erie, and nobody comes forward?
“That’s what the papers called her. Pretty name for something damn ugly. The man who found her torso was looking for driftwood and found a different kind of trunk.”
“So you think that was the Butcher’s first victim?”