Unless I didn’t do it.
Someone paid for Stephen to spend time with me that night – and the same person did something to Tyler. I’m being set up.
Unless I did do it.
Tyler was in my car. I don’t understand how or why – but he was. There was a struggle and he was run over. His blood ended up on the car and, consequently, the garage.
Unless I didn’t do it…
I have no idea what to think and there are far too many gaps in my memory to know much of anything. Could Tyler have been a hundred miles from home at the same hotel as me? Or could Dan, Jason or someone else have planted the dog tag in my glovebox? Or did Tyler break into the house and somehow leave it in my car himself?
I’ve thought this whole time that Tyler had either run off, or got himself into trouble with someone he shouldn’t. But perhaps it’s not about him at all? Perhaps it’s about me? Jason, Dan or someone else has done something to him to get to me.
Or that’s all ego and narcissism because of course it’s nothing to do with me.
The truth is that I have no idea. Everything is a mess.
I’ve not been in the glovebox all week, so the chain could have been in there for days. Equally, it might have been placed in there more recently. Today? Yesterday? It’s chilling to think that the police have been in the house. If they’d asked to search the garage and my car, I’d have said it was fine. If they’d found Tyler’s necklace, I would’ve had no way to explain it. The blood was pooled under where my car would be parked. I’d be prime suspect. It’s only through luck that I’m not.
I’m riddled with that ambivalence as I drive home. There are moments in which I’m convinced this is all down to me; others where I’m convinced that I’m a victim.
It’s early evening when I pull into the garage and, instead of returning Tyler’s dog tag to the glovebox, I bury it at the bottom of my bag. The house is empty anyway; Olivia at work or with friends; Dan is who knows where. I certainly have no idea. I’ve not received any texts and there are no notes on the kitchen counter or fridge.
With the house to myself, I figure I should hide the chain somewhere safer than my bag. It’s not beyond the realms of possibility that the police might want to search here at some point, so indoors is out of the question. I have visions of digging in parks or throwing it in a pond – but it’s too much. I’m already out of my comfort zone, doing things I’d never have pictured myself doing.
There’s an all-weather plastic storage crate at the back of the house secured with a padlock. The lawnmower is inside, along with a selection of scuffed tools. Neither Dan nor I have ever been much for gardening. It all seems like hard work, especially as the grass, weeds and everything else always grows back so quickly. There have been times when it’s like Dan and I are playing a game of chicken with one another. I don’t want to mow the grass and neither does he, so we wait until it’s so long it can’t be ignored. One of us will eventually crack, huffing and puffing about having to do it.
The trowel is caked with dried mud, the tip rounded and blunt. I peep through the back door to make sure nobody has returned home and then carefully tread my way around the edge of the lawn until I’m at the flower bed that runs the length of the fence. It’s scruffy and untended, with wiry shoots of green mixing in among the actual plants. There are two small wooden crosses, one with the name ‘Bertie’ scratched into the wood. He was Olivia’s hamster when she was eight or nine but only survived for eighteen months before she came down to feed him one morning and found him dead in his cage. She cried for an entire weekend and it was her first experience of death. I cried, too – not for Bertie, more for her. Something like that closes the door on youthful innocence and it can never be opened again. Olivia had lost more than a hamster.
The second cross is for Lizzie, a lizard that Olivia kept for a couple of years after Bertie died. She did everything right, with the heat lamps and other expensive equipment – but Lizzie succumbed to nature in much the same way that Bertie did. Olivia didn’t cry that time. She buried the creature herself and then asked if we could get rid of the vivarium. She didn’t want a replacement and that was the last pet we owned.
I kneel and dig in the spot where Lizzie is buried, carefully mounding the dirt at the side. It’s not long until I hit the plastic ice cream tub in which the lizard was laid to rest. As coffins go, a square of plastic with ‘Wall’s Neapolitan’ isn’t the most dignified way to end up. The tub hasn’t degraded at all, though the white is imprinted with a brown sludge. I don’t bother removing the lid, placing the tub on the side as I continue to dig the hole underneath.
My upper arms are burning, my fingers rigid like an old arthritic’s when I decide I’ve gone deep enough. If the garden was to be excavated in its entirety, the dog tag will be found – but the chances seem slim.
I drop the necklace to the bottom of the pit and then start to refill the hole. There is a thick layer of mud, then the ice cream tub – and then I carefully pat down the final mounds, being as careful as I can to keep the surface in a similar style to the rest of the flower bed. I do the final few bits with my hands, rearranging the green shoots into clumps until it’s impossible to tell by eye that anything has moved. I clean much of the mud from the trowel, leaving just enough so that it’s not obvious it’s been used recently, and then return it to the storage locker.
It’s only when I’m about to step back into the house when it hits me what I’ve done. If washing the car was tampering with evidence, then this is literally burying it. I didn’t outright lie to the police but I kept at least one important detail back. This is what guilty people do; hiding and obfuscating.
The only justification I have is that I’m scared of what I might have done. I’m frightened by the gaps in my memory, of the thoughts that I might not be able to trust those around me.
Who am I?
When I get inside, I wash my hands and arms, then clean my shoes. I dry the soles with a towel and put them on the rack near the front door. I might be a guilty hit-and-runner, an evidence tamperer and liar – but at least I don’t have dirty shoes in the house. After that I scrub the filth out from under my fingernails and finally take a spot on the sofa with the laptop, as if nothing has happened.
Natasha’s Saturday was spent walking her dog/rat, then she had her nails done, ate some leaves for lunch and she is currently #chilling with her ‘babez’, who I assume is her boyfriend. I wish I could stop checking up on her but I’m too far gone. The first thing I do when I go online. I scoff at her life but mine is worse. I pull myself away from the gloom and look at the Find Tyler page. There haven’t been any posts in a day.
I’m busy fiddling around on the internet, achieving nothing, learning nothing, when I realise that spending hundreds of pounds on a male escort will leave a paper trail somewhere. Dan and I share a bank account, which is also linked to a pair of credit cards. I suspect this won’t last much longer – but, for now, our salaries each drop into the same place.
It takes me a good ten minutes to find the security gadget needed to log on and another couple more to remember my password. It’s not exactly a forensic money trail created by some boffin at revenue and customs but I click through the login screens until I’m looking at our credit card balance.